所有中國公民均應被要求在死后捐獻器官-bp辯論示范

1、1BPBPDebateDebateDemonstrationDemonstration辯論示范賽文字稿辯論示范賽文字稿辯題：辯題：All_Chinese_citizens_should_be_required_to_donate_gans_after_death.All_Chinese_citizens_should_be_required_to_donate_gans_after_death.【注：涂黃色、藍色等彩色部分為觀點要點或辯

2、論知識點或段落起承轉(zhuǎn)合處?！縋RIMEMINISTERInthestatusquothereisaproblemwiththeamountofreadilyavailablegansinChina.WeastheopeninggovernmenthavefoundthebestsolutionindertoprovidethemostamountofthetransplantableganstoChinesecitizens.There

3、solutiongiventoustodaywasallChinesecitizensshouldberequiredtodonatetheirgansafterdeath.MypartnerIhavecomeupwithsomedefinitionstofurtherclarifythisround.Ourfirstdefinitionisdeath.Wedefineitasbothbraincardiacdeath.Oursecon

4、ddefinitionisgans.Wedefineitasdifferentiatedstructuressuchastheheartliverkidneyseyes.Howeverweareexcludingligaments[系帶紐帶韌帶]skin.We’dalsoliketointerpretthismotionfyoutoday.OneasinweareonlygoingtofocusthisroundtojustmainlC

5、hinaonthefollowinggansheartliverkidneyseyes.Ourmodelfyoutodayisasfollows.IDcardswillbecarriedbyChinesecitizenstheywouldbechangedtoincludethebasicmedicalinfmationsuchastheirbloodtypeanydiseasesinfections[傳染傳染病]thatwouldre

6、ndertheirgansnotusable.POI:CanIaskaquestionYeah.WhenyousaycardiacbraindeathdoyoumeaneitheroccurringatthesametimeInourdefinitionsweassessittobothunderourplaninwhichapersonmustbebothbraincardiacdeadbefeweharvesttheirgans.T

7、ocontinueonwithmymodelwealsohavedecidedthatupondeterminationofbraincardiovulardeathdoctshospitalswillbeallowedtoharvestthegansfromallChinesecitizens.Furthermewe’dalsoliketostatethatallChinesegansdonatedwillgodirectlytoCh

8、inesecitizens.HarvestedgansintheseChinesehospitalswillonlygototheChinesecitizenswillnotgototheInternationalmarket.Somyfirstargumenttodayisthatganswillbemereadilyavailable.I’dliketocomparethestatusquotoourplan.Thestatusqu

9、ocurrentlyhasavolunteeringsystemfgandonationwhichisnotacceptivebecausethere’renotenoughgansfalltheChinesecitizensthatneedtransplants.POI:Notatthistime.(tothegirl)Yeah.(totheboy)OKsinceyourgoalistosavingofliveshowdoyouadd

10、ressthefactthatwaitingfcardiacdeathmakestheharvestgansverydifficultespeciallyheartsWedon’tseeourplanasanymedifficultbecauseunderthestatusquounderourplanit’sthesame.Howeverthedifferencebetweenthestatusquoourplanisthatwewi

11、llbeprovidingmeviableheartsftransplantswhichleadstomepeoplesurviving.Soweseeourplanassavingmelives.Tocontinuewithmycomparisonofthestatusquototheplan.Ourgovernmentmodel3theblackmarket.ThesecondpartofthisisthatcurrentlyChi

12、naisaninternationaldestinationfgantransplants.PeoplefromacrossthewldhavecometoChinatoseekgansthattheycan’tgetintheirhomecountrytheyknowthattheblackmarketisaplacewheretheycanpurchaseit.Asaresultunder…fthesetworeasonsthego

13、vernment’splandoesnoteliminatetheblackmarket.Yes.POI:Butwon’ttheblackmarketreducebecausethattheavailabilitycan’tprovideItwillnotbecausewewillseeacontinuedsupplyofgansfthemarketwhichwillbemysecondpoint.Theplandoesn’tchang

14、ethestatusquo.Therequiringofmatygandonationwillnotcausetheblackmarkettobeeliminated.asaresultthiswillallowfChinatocontinuetobethisdestinationfgandonation.Ontomysecondpointthegovernment’splanwillincentivizefChinesecitizen

15、stoselltheirganstotheblackmarketbefetheydieindertohelptheirfamilies.Thegovernment’splanmatesthatChinesecitizens，whentheydie，willdonatetheirgans.ThismeansthatnomatterwhateveryChinesecitizenmustdonatetheirgansundernocondit

16、ionstheydiehavetheirbodystayintact.ThisleavestwooptionsfChinesecitizens.Thefirstonetheycandiethenwaitfthegovernmenttocomeharvesttheirganstobeputintotheirprogram.Thesecondoptionthatwethinkthatwillbecomemecommonbecauseofth

17、egovernment’splanistheseChinesecitizenswillhaveanincentivetosellnonvitalganstotheblackmarketbefetheydieindertobeabletoprovidefinancialsupptftheirfamilies.Yes.POI:Weseethatinalotofcountriesthathavematyoptoutsystemsthereis

18、n’tthismassiveblackmarketofpeoplesellingtheirgansoutbefetheydie.Weagree.Wethinkthatthereasonthatweseethisinthosecountriesisbecausetheycan’toptout.Howeverinthegovernment’splanallChinesecitizensmustdonateganscannotoptout.A

19、saresulttheywillbeincentivizedtoselltheirganstotheblackmarket.Nothankyou.(POI)Iwanttothrowupanexamplethatwillshowwhythegovernment’splanissonegativeinthissituation.AChineseelderlygrmotherwhoseesherchildrengrchildreninpove

20、rtywillnowlookatthegovernment’splanknowthatifshediesherganswillbeharvested.Shewillnowbeencouragedbythegovernment’splanthatbysellingherganstotheblackmarketshecanprovidesupptfherfamilyhelpthemthroughherdeath.Asaresultweare

21、pushingChinesecitizenstogototheseblackmarketstoselltheirganstoundergoverydangeroussituationstohaveyourgansharvestedwhileyourarestillalive.Buttheblackmarketisnotsafe.Itisnotsanitary.thegovernment’splanisgoingtopushtheseCh

22、inesecitizenswhojustwishtohelptheirfamilytoenterintothismarketsupptthisundergroundillegalactivity.Asaresultweareseeingthatthegovernment，whiletheyaretryingtocreatemeavailabilitytogans，isactuallynegativelyimpactingthesitua