外文翻譯--新拌混凝土的性能

1、<p>　　中文5877字,4125單詞,21800字符</p><p>　　Properties of Fresh Concrete</p><p>　　Edited by H.-J. Wierig</p><p>　　Fresh concrete is a mixture of water, cement, aggregate and admixtur

2、e (if any). After mixing, operations such as transporting, placing, compacting and finishing of fresh concrete can all considerably affect the properties of hardened concrete. It is important that the constituent materia

3、ls remain uniformly distributed within the concrete mass during the various stages of its handling and that full compaction is achieved. When either of these conditions is not satisfied the properties of the resu</p&g

4、t;<p>　　The characteristics of fresh concrete which affect full compaction are its consistency, mobility and compactability. In concrete practice these are often collectively known as workability. The ability of c

5、oncrete to maintain its uniformity is governed by its stability, which depends on its consistency and its cohesiveness. Since the methods employed for conveying, placing and consolidatingd a concrete mix, as well as the

6、nature of the section to be cast, may vary from job to job it follows that </p><p>　　In spite of its importance, the behaviour of plastic concrete often tends to be overlooked. It is recommended that student

7、s should learn to appreciate the significance of the various characteristics of concrete in its plastic state and know how these may alter during operations involved in casting a concrete structure.</p><p>　

8、　13.1 Workability</p><p>　　Workability of concrete has never been precisely defined. For practical purposes it generally implies the ease with which a concrete mix can be handled from the mixer to its finall

9、y compacted shape. The three main characteristics of the property are consistency, mobility and compactability. Consistency is a measure of wetness or fluidity. Mobility defines the ease with which a mix can flow into an

10、d completely fill the formwork or mould. Compactability is the ease with which a given mix can be fu</p><p>　　Another commonly accepted definition of workability is related to the amount of useful internal w

11、ork necessary to produce full compaction. It should be appreciated that the necessary work again depends on the nature of the section being cast. Measurement of internal work presents many difficulties and several method

12、s have been developed for this purpose but none gives an absolute measure of workability.</p><p>　　The tests commonly used for measuring workability do not measure the individual characteristics (consistency

13、, mobility and compactability) of workability. However, they do provide useful and practical guidance on the workability of a mix. Workability affects the quality of concrete and has a direct bearing on cost so that, for

14、 example, an unworkable concrete mix requires more time and labour for full compaction. It is most important that a realistic assessment is made of the workability required</p><p>　　13.2 Measurement of Worka

15、bility</p><p>　　Three tests widely used for measuring workability are the slump, compacting factor and V-B consistometer tests (figure 13.1). These are standard tests in the United Kingdom and are described

16、in detail in BS 1881: Part 2. Their use is also recommended in CP 110: Part 1. It is important to note that there is no single relationship between the slump, compacting factor and V-B results for different concretes. In

17、 the following sections the salient features of these tests together with their merits an</p><p>　　Slump Test</p><p>　　This test was developed by Chapman in the United States in 1913. A 300 mm h

18、igh concrete cone, prepared under standard conditions (BS 1881: Part 2) is allowed to subside and the slump or reduction in height of the cone is taken to be a measure of workability. The apparatus is inexpensive, portab

19、le and robustd and is the simplest of all the methods employed for measuring workability. It is not surprising that, in spite of its several limitations, the slump test has retained its popularity.</p><p>　　

20、Figure 13.1 Apparatus for workability measurement: (a) slump cone, (b) compacting factor and (c) V-B consistometer</p><p>　　The test primarily measures the consistency of plastic concrete and although it is

21、difficult to see any significant relationship between slump and workability as defined previously, it is suitable for detecting changes in workability. For example, an increase in the water content or deficiency in the p

22、roportion of fine aggregate results in an increase in slump. Although the test is suitable for quality-control purposes it should be remembered that it is generally considered to be unsuitable for </p><p>　　

23、Figure 13.2 Three main types of slump</p><p>　　The three types of slump usually observed are true slump, shear slump and collapse slump, as illustrated in figure 13.2. A true slump is observed with cohesive

24、and rich mixes for which the slump is generally sensitive to variations in workability. A collapse slump is usually associated with very wet mixes and is generally indicative of poor quality concrete and most frequently

25、results from segregation of its constituent materials. Shear slump occurs more often in leaner mixes than in rich ones a</p><p>　　The standard slump apparatus is only suitable for concretes in which the maxi

26、mum aggregate size does not exceed 37.5 mm. It should be noted that the value of slump changes with time after mixing owing to normal hydration processes and evaporation of some of the free water, and it is desirable the

27、refore that tests are performed within a fixed period of time.</p><p>　　Compacting Factor Test</p><p>　　This test, developed in the United Kingdom by Glanville et al. (1947), measures the degre

28、e of compaction for a standard amount of work and thus offers a direct and reasonably reliable assessment of the workability of concrete as previously defined. The apparatus is a relatively simple mechanical contrivance

29、(figure 13.1) and is fully described in BS 1881: Part 2. The test requires measurement of the weights of the partially and fully compacted concrete and the ratio of the partially compacted we</p><p>　　It sho

30、uld also be appreciated that, strictly speaking, some of the basic assumptions of the test are not correct. The work done to overcome surface friction of the measuring cylinder probably varies with the characteristics of

31、 the mix. It has been shown by Cusens (1956) that for concretes with very low workability the actual work required to obtain full compaction depends on the richness of a mix while the compacting factor remains sensibly u

32、naffected. Thus it follows that the generally held bel</p><p>　　V-B Consistometer Test</p><p>　　This test was developed in Sweden by Bhrner (1940) (see figure 13.1). Although generally regarded

33、as a test primarily used in research its potential is now more widely acknowledged in industry and the test is gradually being accepted. In this test (BS 1881: Part 2) the time taken to transform, by means of vibration,

34、a standard cone of concrete to a compacted flat cylindrical mass is recorded. This is known as the V-B time, in seconds, and is stated to the nearest 0.5 s. Unlike the two previous t</p><p>　　The test is sui

35、table for a wide range of mixes and, unlike the slump and compacting factor tests, it is sensitive to variations in workability of very dry and also air-entrained concretes. It is also more sensitive to variation in aggr

36、egate characteristics such as shape and surface texture. The reproducibility of results is good. As for other tests its accuracy tends to decrease with increasing maximum size of aggregate; above 19.0 mm the test results

37、 become somewhat unreliable. For concretes re</p><p>　　13.3 Factors Affecting Workability</p><p>　　Various factors known to influence the workability of a freshly mixed concrete are shown in fig

38、ure 13.3. From the following discussion it will be apparent that a change in workability associated with the constituent materials is mainly affected by water content and specific surface of cement and aggregate.</p&g

39、t;<p>　　Cement and Water</p><p>　　Figure 13.3 Factors affecting workability of fresh conrete</p><p>　　Typical relationships between the cement-water ratio (by volume) and the volume frac

40、tion of cement for different workabilities are shown in figure 15.5. The change in workability for a given change in cement-water ratio is greater when the water content is changed than when only the cement content is ch

41、anged. In general the effect of the cement content is greater for richer mixes. Hughes (1971) has shown that similar linear relationships exist irrespective of the properties of the constituent ma</p><p>　　F

42、or a given mix, the workability of the concrete decreases as the fineness of the cement increases as a result of the increased specific surface, this effect being more marked in rich mixtures. It should also be noted tha

43、t the finer cements improve the cohesiveness of a mix. With the exception of gypsum, the composition of cement has no apparent effect on workability. Unstable gypsum is responsible for false set, which can impair workabi

44、lity unless prolonged mixing or remixing of the fresh concr</p><p>　　Admixtures</p><p>　　The principal admixtures affecting improvement in the workability of concrete are water-reducing and air-

45、entraining agents. The extent of the increase in workability is dependent on the type and amount of admixture used and the general characteristics of the fresh concrete.</p><p>　　Workability admixtures are u

46、sed to increase workability while the mix proportions are kept constant or to reduce the water content while maintaining constant workability. The former results in a slight reduction in concrete strength.</p><

47、;p>　　Air-entraining agents are by far the most commonly used workability admixtures because they also improve both the cohesiveness of the plastic concrete and the frost resistance of the resulting hardened concrete.

48、Two points of practical importance concerning air-entrained concrete are that for a given amount of entrained air, the increase in workability tends to be smaller for concretes containing rounded aggregates or low cement

49、-water ratios (by volume) and, in general, the rate of increase in w</p><p><b>　　Aggregate</b></p><p>　　For given cement, water and aggregate contents, the workability of concrete is

50、 mainly influenced by the total surface area of the aggregate. The surface area is governed by the maximum size, grading and shape of the aggregate. Workability decreases as the specific surface increases, since this req

51、uires a greater proportion of cement paste to wet the aggregate particles, thus leaving a smaller amount of paste for lubrication. It follows that, all other conditions being equal, the workability will</p><p&

52、gt;　　TABLE 13.1</p><p>　　Effect of maximum size of aggregate of similar grading zone on aggregate-cement ratio of concrete having water-cement ratio of 0.55 by weight, based on McIntosh (1964)</p><

53、;p>　　TABLE 13.2</p><p>　　Effect of aggregate grading (maximum size 19.0 mm) on aggregate-cement ratio of concrete having medium workability and water-cement ratio of 0.55 by weight, based on McIntosh (196

54、4)</p><p>　　Figure 13.4 Effect of aggregate shape on aggregate-cement ratio of concretes for different workabilities, based on Cornelius (1970)</p><p>　　Several methods have been developed for e

55、valuating the shape of aggregate, a subject discussed in chapter 12. Angularity factors together with grading modulus and equivalent mean diameter provide a means of considering the respective effects of shape, size and

56、grading of aggregate (see chapter 15). Since the strength of a fully compacted concrete, for given materials and cement-water ratio, is not dependent on the ratio of coarse to fine aggregate, maximum economy can be obtai

57、ned by using the co</p><p>　　Figure 13.5 A typical relationship between workability and coarse aggregate content of concrete, based on Hughes (1960)</p><p>　　The effect of surface texture on wor

58、kability is shown in figure 13.6. It can be seen that aggregates with a smooth texture result in higher workabilities than aggregates with a rough texture. Absorption characteristics of aggregate also affect workability

59、where dry or partially dry aggregates are used. In such a case workability drops, the extent of the reduction being dependent on the aggregate content and its absorption capacity.</p><p>　　Ambient Conditions

60、</p><p>　　Environmental factors that may cause a reduction in workability are temperature, humidity and wind velocityd. For a given concrete, changes in workability are governed by the rate of hydration of

61、the cement and the rate of evaporation of water. Therefore both the time interval from the commencement of mixing to compaction and the conditions of exposure influence the reduction in workability. An increase in the te

62、mperature speeds up the rate at which water is used for hydration as well as its los</p><p>　　Figure 13.6 Effect of aggregate surface texture on aggregate-cement ratio of concretes for different workabilitie

63、s, based on Cornelius (1970)</p><p><b>　　Time</b></p><p>　　The time that elapses between mixing of concrete and its final compaction depends on the general conditions of work such as

64、 the distance between the mixer and the point of placing, site procedures and general management. The associated reduction in workability is a direct result of loss of free water with time through evaporation, aggregate

65、absorption and initial hydration of the cement. The rate of loss of workability is affected by certain characteristics of the constituent materials, for exam</p><p>　　For a given concrete and set of ambient

66、conditions, the rate of loss of workability with time depends on the conditions of handling. Where concrete remains undisturbed after mixing until it is placed, the loss of workability during the first hour can be substa

67、ntial, the rate of loss of workability decreasing with time as illustrated by curve A in figure 13.7. On the other hand, if it is continuously agitated, as in the case of ready-mixed concrete, the loss of workability is

68、reduced, particularl</p><p>　　For practical purposes, loss of workability assumes importance when concrete becomes so unworkable that it cannot be effectively compacted, with the result that its strength and

69、 other properties become adversely affected. Corrective measures frequently taken to ensure that concrete at the time of placing has the desired workability are either an initial increase in the water content or an incre

70、ase in the water content with further mixing shortly before the concrete is discharged. When this resul</p><p>　　Figure 13.7 Loss of workability of concrete with time: (A) no agitation and (B) continuously a

71、gitated after mixing</p><p>　　13.4 Stability</p><p>　　Apart from being sufficiently workable, fresh concrete should have a composition such that its constituent materials remain uniformly distri

72、buted in the concrete during both the period between mixing and compaction and the period following compaction before the concrete stiffens. Because of differences in the particle size and specific gravities of the const

73、ituent materials there exists a natural tendency for them to separate. Concrete capable of maintaining the required uniformity is said to be</p><p>　　Segregation</p><p>　　When there is a signifi

74、cant tendency for the large and fine particles in a mix to become separated, segregation is said to have occurred. In general, the less cohesive the mix the greater the tendency for segregation to occur. Segregation is g

75、overned by the total specific surface of the solid particles including cement and the quantity of mortar in the mix. Harsh, extremely wet and dry mixes as well as those deficient in sand, particularly the finer particles

76、, are prone to segregation. As far as</p><p>　　Blemishes, sand streaks, porous layers and honeycombing are a direct result of segregation. These features are not only unsightly but also adversely affect stre

77、ngth, durability and other properties of the hardened concrete. It is important to realize that the effects of segregation may not be indicated by the routine strength tests on control specimens since the conditions of p

78、lacing and compaction of the specimens differ from those in the actual structure. There are no specific rules for suspec</p><p><b>　　Bleeding</b></p><p>　　During compaction and unti

79、l the cement paste has hardened there is a natural tendency for the solid particles, depending on size and specific gravity, to exhibit a downward movement. Where the consistency of a mix is such that it is unable to hol

80、d all its water some of it is gradually displaced and rises to the surface, and some may also leak through the joints of the formwork. Separation of water from a mix in this manner is known as bleeding. While some of the

81、 water reaches the top surface som</p><p>　　The risk of bleeding increases when concrete is compacted by vibration although this may be minimized by using a correctly designed mix and ensuring that the concr

82、ete is not over-vibrated. Rich mixes tend to bleed less than lean mixes. The type of cement employed is also important, the tendency for bleeding to occur decreasing as the fineness of the cement or its alkaline and tric

83、alcium aluminate (C3A) content increases. Air-entrainment provides another very effective means of controlling bleedi</p><p><b>　　新拌混凝土的性能</b></p><p>　　作者：H.-J. Wierig</p><

84、;p>　　新拌混凝土為水、水泥、集料和外加劑（如果有的話）的混合物。攪拌后，新拌混凝土的操作如輸送、澆注、密實(shí)和終飾也會(huì)顯著影響硬化混凝土的性能。組成材料在施工的不同時(shí)期保持在混凝土中的均勻分布及完全密實(shí)是很重要的。若這些條件不理想，成品硬化混凝土的性能如強(qiáng)度和耐久性就有不利影響。</p><p>　　新拌混凝土影響完全密實(shí)的特性是其稠度、流動(dòng)性和密實(shí)性。在混凝土實(shí)踐中這些一起被稱為和易性?；炷辆S持其均勻

85、性的能力由其穩(wěn)定性控制，穩(wěn)定性又取決于稠度和粘聚性。由于對(duì)混凝土拌和物運(yùn)輸、澆注和搗固采用的方法與澆注構(gòu)件的性質(zhì)一樣隨工程不同而異，因此相應(yīng)的和易性和穩(wěn)定性要求也會(huì)改變。對(duì)特定工作新拌混凝土的適應(yīng)性的評(píng)定在某種程度上總存在人為判斷的問題。</p><p>　　盡管很重要，但塑性混凝土的行為通常被忽視。建議學(xué)生應(yīng)學(xué)會(huì)鑒定塑性狀態(tài)混凝土的不同特性的重要性，了解在包括澆注混凝土結(jié)構(gòu)的施工操作時(shí)如何去改變它們。</

86、p><p><b>　　和易性</b></p><p>　　混凝土的和易性從未被準(zhǔn)確定義。實(shí)踐時(shí)一般認(rèn)為是指混凝土拌和物從攪拌機(jī)施工到其最終密實(shí)形狀的容易程度。和易性的三個(gè)主要特性是稠度、流動(dòng)性和密實(shí)性。稠度指濕潤(rùn)度或流度的度量。流動(dòng)性指拌和物流進(jìn)并完全充滿模板或模具的容易程度。密實(shí)性指給定拌和物完全密實(shí)，排除所有截留空氣的容易程度。本章要求的拌和物和易性不僅取決于組成材

87、料的特性和相應(yīng)比例，而且取決于（1）運(yùn)輸和密實(shí)采用的方法，（2）模板或模具的尺寸、形狀和表面粗糙度，（3）鋼筋的數(shù)量和間距（布筋）。</p><p>　　另一個(gè)普遍接受和易性的定義指產(chǎn)生完全密實(shí)所必須的有用內(nèi)功的數(shù)量。應(yīng)認(rèn)識(shí)到必需功又取決于被澆注構(gòu)件的性質(zhì)。內(nèi)功的確定存在許多困難，為此已發(fā)展了幾種方法，但沒有一種能給出和易性的絕對(duì)確定。</p><p>　　通常用于確定和易性的實(shí)驗(yàn)不能確定

88、和易性的單一特性（稠度、流動(dòng)性和密實(shí)性）。然而它們的確給出了拌和物和易性的一個(gè)有用、實(shí)際的指導(dǎo)。和易性影響混凝土的質(zhì)量，并直接影響成本，如和易性不好的混凝土拌和物完全密實(shí)要求更多時(shí)間和勞力。最重要的是在對(duì)適宜的混凝土配比下任何結(jié)論之前要求對(duì)給定現(xiàn)場(chǎng)條件的和易性作出現(xiàn)實(shí)評(píng)定。</p><p><b>　　和易性的確定</b></p><p>　　三個(gè)廣泛應(yīng)用確定和易性的

89、實(shí)驗(yàn)是坍落度、密實(shí)系數(shù)和V-B稠度計(jì)實(shí)驗(yàn)（圖13.1），是英國(guó)的標(biāo)準(zhǔn)實(shí)驗(yàn)，詳細(xì)描述在英標(biāo)1881第2部分。在實(shí)施法規(guī)110第1部分也推薦使用。重要的是注意到不同混凝土的坍落度、密實(shí)系數(shù)和V-B值間沒有單一關(guān)系。下列章節(jié)討論了這些實(shí)驗(yàn)的突出特點(diǎn)及其優(yōu)點(diǎn)和局限性。</p><p><b>　　坍落度實(shí)驗(yàn)</b></p><p>　　此實(shí)驗(yàn)由美國(guó)Chapman于1913年發(fā)

90、展的。標(biāo)準(zhǔn)條件（英標(biāo)1881第2部分）下準(zhǔn)備的300mm高混凝土圓錐下沉，錐體下沉或高度的降低被確定為和易性的度量。儀器便宜、輕便、結(jié)實(shí)，是所有確定和易性方法中最簡(jiǎn)單的。盡管存在一些局限性，坍落度實(shí)驗(yàn)的普及是不足為奇的。</p><p>　　實(shí)驗(yàn)主要確定塑性混凝土的稠度，盡管很難看出坍落度與和易性有象先前定義的任何顯著聯(lián)系，但它適用于檢測(cè)和易性的改變。如，用水量增加或細(xì)集料比例不足會(huì)引起坍落度增加。實(shí)驗(yàn)適用于質(zhì)量

91、控制目的，但應(yīng)記住一般認(rèn)為不適用于配比設(shè)計(jì)，因密實(shí)需不同工作量的混凝土可能有相似的坍落度數(shù)值。實(shí)驗(yàn)檢測(cè)不同拌和物和易性改變的靈敏性和可靠性主要取決于其對(duì)稠度的靈敏性。實(shí)驗(yàn)不適用于很干或濕的拌和物。坍落度為0或接近0的很干拌和物，和易性的一般改變不會(huì)引起坍落度有可測(cè)量的變化。對(duì)濕拌和物，混凝土的完全崩坍會(huì)產(chǎn)生不可信的坍落度值。</p><p>　　圖13.1儀器對(duì)工作性測(cè)量 (a) 坍落度, (b) 壓縮因子and

92、 (c) V-B .濃度測(cè)試器</p><p>　　通常觀察的三種坍落度為真實(shí)坍落度、剪切坍落度和崩坍坍落度，見插圖13.2。粘性富拌和物可看到真實(shí)坍落度，一般對(duì)和易性改變較敏感。剪切坍落度通常有很濕拌和物相關(guān)，一般表現(xiàn)為差質(zhì)量的混凝土，最常是由組成材料的離析引起。崩坍坍落度在貧拌和物中比富拌和物更常發(fā)生，指缺少粘性，一般與干硬性拌和物（砂漿含量少）相關(guān)。只要出現(xiàn)剪切坍落度就應(yīng)重復(fù)實(shí)驗(yàn)，若一再重復(fù)，就應(yīng)記載此實(shí)驗(yàn)

93、現(xiàn)象和結(jié)果，因?yàn)楂@得相差大的不同坍落度值取決于坍落度是真實(shí)或是剪切形式。</p><p>　　標(biāo)準(zhǔn)坍落度儀器僅適用于集料最大粒徑不超過37.5mm的混凝土。應(yīng)注意坍落度值隨攪拌后時(shí)間而改變，因?yàn)檎５乃鸵恍┯坞x水的蒸發(fā)，因此在一固定時(shí)間內(nèi)完成實(shí)驗(yàn)是比較理想的。</p><p>　　圖13.2三種坍落度</p><p><b>　　密實(shí)系數(shù)實(shí)驗(yàn)</

94、b></p><p>　　由英國(guó)Glanville（1947）等發(fā)展的這個(gè)實(shí)驗(yàn)確定對(duì)于標(biāo)準(zhǔn)工作量下的密實(shí)程度，因此給出了如前定義的混凝土和易性的直接而合理可信的評(píng)價(jià)。儀器是相對(duì)簡(jiǎn)單的機(jī)械裝置（圖13.1），描述在英標(biāo)1881第2部分中。實(shí)驗(yàn)要求確定部分和完全密實(shí)混凝土的重量，部分對(duì)完全密實(shí)重量的比值總小于1，即是密實(shí)系數(shù)。對(duì)于普通范圍的混凝土，密實(shí)系數(shù)為0.80~0.92。實(shí)驗(yàn)尤其適用于坍落度實(shí)驗(yàn)不理想的較

95、干拌和物。在普通范圍的和易性之外時(shí)密實(shí)系數(shù)靈敏性減小，通常密實(shí)系數(shù)超過0.92時(shí)就是不理想的。</p><p>　　也應(yīng)認(rèn)識(shí)到，嚴(yán)格地說，實(shí)驗(yàn)的一些基本假設(shè)是不正確的。用于克服檢測(cè)圓柱體的表面摩擦的工作可能隨拌和物的特性而異。Cusens（1956）指出對(duì)很低和易性的混凝土，當(dāng)密實(shí)系數(shù)保持明顯不變時(shí)獲得完全密實(shí)要求的實(shí)際工作取決于拌和物的富度。因此通常認(rèn)為有相同密實(shí)系數(shù)的混凝土完全密實(shí)要求的工作量相同的觀念不總是

96、正確的。應(yīng)注意的另一點(diǎn)是澆注混凝土到檢測(cè)圓柱體的程序與現(xiàn)場(chǎng)通常采用的方法并不相同。與坍落度實(shí)驗(yàn)一樣，密實(shí)系數(shù)的確定必須在某一特定時(shí)間內(nèi)。標(biāo)準(zhǔn)儀器適用于集料最大粒徑達(dá)37.5mm的混凝土。</p><p><b>　　V-B稠度計(jì)實(shí)驗(yàn)</b></p><p>　　實(shí)驗(yàn)由瑞典Bhrner（1940）發(fā)展（看圖13.1）。盡管一般將其作為主要用于研究的實(shí)驗(yàn)，但其潛力現(xiàn)在正在

97、工業(yè)中被更廣泛公認(rèn)，實(shí)驗(yàn)逐漸被接受。實(shí)驗(yàn)中（英標(biāo)1881第2部分）記錄了通過振動(dòng)把一個(gè)標(biāo)準(zhǔn)混凝土圓錐變成密實(shí)的平圓柱體所用的時(shí)間，即V-B時(shí)間，用s做單位，規(guī)定精確到0.5s。與前兩個(gè)實(shí)驗(yàn)不同，此實(shí)驗(yàn)處理混凝土與實(shí)際密實(shí)混凝土方法類似。而且，此實(shí)驗(yàn)對(duì)稠度、流動(dòng)性和密實(shí)性改變敏感，因此認(rèn)為在實(shí)驗(yàn)結(jié)果與現(xiàn)場(chǎng)和易性評(píng)定之間存在合理的相關(guān)關(guān)系。</p><p>　　實(shí)驗(yàn)適用于大范圍拌和物，與坍落度和密實(shí)系數(shù)實(shí)驗(yàn)不同，它對(duì)

98、很干和引氣混凝土和易性變化很敏感，對(duì)集料特性如形狀和表面紋理的變化也更敏感。實(shí)驗(yàn)結(jié)果的復(fù)驗(yàn)性好。如其它實(shí)驗(yàn)一樣，其準(zhǔn)確性趨于隨集料最大粒徑增加而降低，大于19.0mm實(shí)驗(yàn)結(jié)果有點(diǎn)不可信。對(duì)于密實(shí)要求很少振動(dòng)的混凝土V-B時(shí)間僅約3s。這樣的結(jié)果可能可信度比大V-B時(shí)間要低，因?yàn)楣烙?jì)時(shí)間終點(diǎn)（混凝土接觸塑料盤的整個(gè)下面）比較困難。在和易性范圍的另一面，如很干拌和物，記錄的V-B時(shí)間可能超過真實(shí)和易性，因?yàn)橄该鞅P下截留的氣泡要求延長(zhǎng)振動(dòng)